Stick or Twist – Mancini or Mourinho

Jose Mourinho may leave Real Madrid at the end of the season. Then again he may not, but the press reckon he will so that seems enough to start some speculation about which English team he’ll be managing next season.

To be fair, it isn’t groundless speculation. It looks like Barcelona are going to retain their Spanish crown and the top men at Los Blancos have a notoriously itchy collective trigger finger. If Mourinho can’t topple the Catalan giansts domestically and fails to deliver the Champions League title they so desperately crave it isn’t unthinkable that he’ll get the bullet. Then again, Jose himself is hardly renowned for sticking around – his relationship with Real Madrid has never looked like one that would last more than a couple of seasons anyway, so a premature end would hardly be a shock.

Naturally, in all the speculation about where Jose might go next should he vacate the Madrid hot-seat, City’s name has crept up more than once. The issue here should not be whether or not we would welcome Mourinho at all. He is a proven winner, he hasn’t lost a home league game at home for nine years and he’s a trophy magnet. So, in principal, I’d love him at City. I’m very much a fan.

The issue though should be this – what need is there to dispense of the services of Roberto Mancini? We’ve just made it to the semi-final of The FA Cup for the first time since 1981 and we’re still looking good for fourth place.

Let’s imagine City finish fourth and win The FA Cup, then Mourinho gets the axe and declares an interest in managing City. What should the decision makers at Eastlands do? Do they  keep Mancini, who would’ve met the minumum league target and ended our trophyless era, or should they be more ruthless and make a move for “The Special One”? As the cliche goes, there is no room for sentiment in football.

I don’t have an answer here. My heart very much tells me that you “stick” with Mancini, but I am aware that a lot of City fans would disagree. I don’t think The Blues have ever fully taken the Italian to their hearts.

Normally I would argue that short-termism hasn’t done us any good for us for the last three decades, why not finally aim for some stability. Here’s the thing though – never before has the “twist” option been to tempt the worlds’ greatest  manager to the club.

Like I say, I don’t have an answer. I’m just rambling, almost aimlessly, truth be told. I don’t know what I think, but as a supporter it is a point worth considering as it is not difficult to imagine it is a point being considered by City’s top brass.

Advertisements

About richardtheburns

I'm a 22 year old Manchester City fan and season ticket holder. I'm a City blogger and a regular contribuor to King of the Kippax. Come inside and enjoy!
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Stick or Twist – Mancini or Mourinho

  1. There’s all sorts of speculation of where he’ll end up, and then counter arguements to challenge the speculation! I’m not a city fan but I think Mancini has done a fantastic job considering the pressure, the media hype and the rumours that the players don’t like him. Shortsighted boardroom antics have seen your club hire and fire at the drop of a hat. But if the ‘Special One’ becomes available I think City should have their trigger finger on the ready.

  2. Tony says:

    good blog -for my money Id stick with Mancini – as good as Jose he is, he just doesnt stay in one place long enough

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s